Introduction
The Payment Systems Regulator (PSR) and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) have published a joint Consultation Paper (“CP24/9”) exploring the current landscape, competitive dynamics, opportunities, risks and regulatory considerations surrounding digital wallets in the UK. This initiative seeks to gather information from stakeholders to inform future regulatory actions aimed at promoting competition and protecting consumers.
The various questions outlined in the Consultation Paper relate to:
- The features and functionality of Digital Wallets
- Digital wallets and how payments are initiated
- The current state of competition and barriers to entry in the digital wallet market
- The impact of digital wallets to financial resilience and systemic risk within the financial system
- Consumer protection
- The role of regulatory bodies and legal powers
What are Digital Wallets?
Digital wallets are electronic devices or software applications that allow users/consumers to store and manage their payment information securely. They facilitate various financial transactions, such as making payments, transferring money and storing digital versions of loyalty cards, tickets and other credentials. Notable examples of such digital wallets that have become an integral part of modern life are digital wallets provided by big tech firms are Apple Pay, Google Wallet, Samsung Pay and PayPal.
Market Overview
Digital wallets have become increasingly popular among consumers due to their convenience and speed. They offer various functionalities, including contactless payments, online transactions and storage of payment credentials. Big tech firms have expanded into and dominate the market, often integrated with broader mobile ecosystems.
Consumer Protection and Experience
The FCA maintains a consumer-centric approach, addressing key concerns in the Consultation Paper in order to ensure that financial markets continue to work well for consumers, businesses and the competitiveness and growth of the UK economy.
Consumer adoption of digital wallets is influenced by various factors, including perceived security, ease of use and acceptance by merchants. The CP24/9 seeks to understand:
- Security Concerns: In particular, how digital wallets ensure the security of transactions and protect user data.
- Consumer Experience: The ease with which consumers can use digital wallets across different platforms and payment scenarios.
- Merchant Acceptance: The extent to which merchants support digital wallet payments, which directly impacts consumer adoption.
Barriers to Entry and Competition
The CP24/9 also highlights several factors that the PSR and FCA have identified and may restrict competition and innovation in the digital wallet market:
- Platform Exclusivity: Major digital wallets are often tied to specific mobile operating systems (i.e. Apple and Google), limiting consumer choice and hindering competition.
- Access to Technology: New entrants may face challenges accessing essential technologies and infrastructure, such as Near Field Communication (NFC) technology. This could be attributed to Apple’s restrictions on third party access to the iPhone’s NFC chip, for example.
- Interchange Fees: Digital wallet providers often incur interchange fees on transactions, which can be a significant cost barrier for new market entrants.
Key Objectives of the Consultation Paper
- Understanding market dynamics by engaging with stakeholders across the payments and financial systems landscape and gain insights into how digital wallets function within the broader payments ecosystem, their impact on competition, and potential barriers to entry for new market players.
- Assessing consumer experience by evaluating the benefits and challenges faced by consumers using digital wallets, including issues related to security, convenience, and access.
- Identifying the need for potential regulatory interventions to ensure a fair, competitive, and innovative market for digital wallets as well as the regulatory overlap between the FCA, PSR and Competition and Markets Authority (CMA).
Potential Regulatory Interventions
To foster a more competitive and consumer-friendly market, several areas where regulatory intervention might be necessary are outlined:
- Considering interoperability between different digital wallets and payment systems to enhance consumer choice and competition.
- Access to technology and fair access to essential payment technologies for all market players.
- Improving transparency around fees associated with digital wallet transactions to help consumers make informed choices.
This consultation marks a significant step towards understanding and potentially regulating the digital wallet market in the UK. By engaging with stakeholders and gathering detailed information, the PSR and FCA aim to ensure that the market remains competitive, innovative and beneficial for consumers.
Stakeholders are encouraged to submit their responses by September 13, 2024. The findings from this consultation will help shape future regulatory actions and the ongoing collaboration with the CMA and the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 once enacted, to address digital market issues effectively.
How Complyport can help
Robust Operational Resilience and Cyber Security systems and controls are essential to ensuring the security and undisrupted business continuity of your company’s services. Complyport’s specialised team can ensure your company meets the latest regulatory standards and best practices. The services we offer include:
- SOC2 Type II Audit
- REP018 Operational and Security RISK Report
- Operational Resilience Audit
- IT & Cybersecurity Audit
- SWIFT Attestation
Complete the form below to book a FREE consultation.
Ask ViCA, your Virtual Compliance Assistant. Claim your complimentary 20 queries today!
